Skip to main

Best Pizza in Watertown

Italian Pizza & Family-Friendly Dining in Watertown

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Wings Bone In (10)

Choice of regular bone in wings

Add Item

Boneless Wings (10)

Boneless wings

Add Item

Calzone

Our signature calzone stuffed with your favorite fillings (limit 4 fillings). Ricotta cheese available upon request

Add Item

Meat Lover Pizza

Ham, bacon, meatball, pepperoni, sausage

Add Item

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken and hot sauce, served with bleu cheese

Add Item

Cordon Bleu Pizza

Breaded chicken, ham, swiss cheese, mozzarella and alfredo

Add Item

Homemade Chicken Parmesan

Chicken breast covered with our homemade pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese, served with spaghetti

Add Item

Welcome to Papa Tino's Pizzeria🍽️

Welcome to Papa Tino's Pizzeria🍽️
Step into Papa Tino's Pizzeria, your go-to spot for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Watertown, NY. Located at 716 Mill St, we serve handcrafted pizzas, classic pasta dishes, and fresh salads in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Join us for dine-in, takeout, or delivery today!

The Home of Legendary Pizza🍕

The Home of Legendary Pizza🍕
Get ready to experience the ultimate pizza adventure at Papa Tino's Pizzeria! Known for our giant 30-inch pizza, we serve up specialty pies crafted with fresh dough, signature sauce, premium cheese, and bold flavors. Don't forget to check out our daily specials for unbeatable deals!
Explore Our Menu
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Craving pizza? Ordering from Papa Tino's has never been easier! Simply visit our website to browse our full menu, customize your order, and have your favorite dishes delivered or ready for pickup. Enjoy the convenience of ordering online and savoring authentic Italian flavors in no time!
Order Now

Papa Tino's Food Gallery📷

Dive into our gallery and get a glimpse of the delicious meals waiting for you at our Watertown location. Whether it’s a classic pizza, a hearty stromboli, or a cheesy calzone, we’ve got something to satisfy every craving.

Catering For All Occasions

Catering For All Occasions
Whether it's a family gathering, corporate event, or special celebration, Papa Tino’s Pizzeria offers catering that’s sure to wow! Our delicious pizzas, pastas, and more are prepared with the finest ingredients and delivered fresh. Ready to make your event unforgettable? Let us handle the food!
Plan With Us

Homemade Pasta Sauce!

Homemade Pasta Sauce!
We're excited to offer something special at Papa Tino's Pizzeria! Now you can enjoy our homemade pasta sauce at home. Made with the same care and quality as our restaurant dishes, it's perfect for your own kitchen. Add a touch of Papa Tino's to your meals—pick up our sauce today and bring the taste of Italy into your home!

Visit Us and Taste the Difference

Visit Us and Taste the Difference
Come by Papa Tino’s Pizzeria and experience authentic, handcrafted dishes made with the finest ingredients. Whether you're craving a giant 30-inch pizza or a comforting pasta, we’ve got something for every taste. Located at 716 Mill St, Watertown, NY, we’re ready to serve you with a smile! Enjoy your meal in our cozy atmosphere or order for takeout. See you soon!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

My first time and I was blown away by the pizza and wings. The pizza I ordered a large (thinking about other places) and the thing was huge and loaded with toppings, the taste was great. I will be back. Thank you for the great food.

Richard C.

Richard C.

We had a giant pizza and a salad. The food was great! Would highly recommend for a party. We fed six hungry teenagers, two adults, and still had a few slices left over to have for lunch tomorrow! The pizza barely fit on my stove top and the delivery lady was very kind and brought it into our house for us. We've ordered party pizzas before, but I've never seen a pizza this big!

Rachael P.

Rachael P.

My new favorite place. some of the best Italian food I've ever had, tried many different things and they're all fantastic

Jason l.

Jason l.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Catering

Unlock Papa Tino's Rewards 🎁

Unlock Papa Tino's Rewards 🎁

At Papa Tino’s Pizzeria, we believe in rewarding our loyal customers! Sign up for our rewards program and start earning points with every order. From free pizzas to exclusive discounts, enjoy delicious rewards that make your next visit even better. Join today and start earning

Frequently asked questions

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Watertown, NY at 716 Mill St

Our location